He Says Sorry. But the Thing He's Sorry For Keeps Happening.
You've had this exact conversation. Maybe more than once. He does something that hurts you — dismisses your feelings in front of other people, cancels last minute again, says something sharp and then pretends it was a joke. You bring it up. He apologises. Really apologises. You can see he means it.
You feel relief. Two weeks later, you're back in this exact spot.
This pattern works, in part, because of something true about you: you believe people can change. You are right — they can. But the belief that someone has the capacity to grow is not the same as evidence that they are choosing to. And genuine apologies — warm, feeling apologies — can look like evidence when they're not.
An apology is a response to being caught. Changed behaviour is a choice made when no one is watching.
He apologised again last night. Sat with me for two hours. Said all the right things. I believed him — and I hated that I believed him. Because I've believed him before. And I know what comes next.
In the Josh & Tonya series, this is Josh's most honest struggle. He isn't careless. He feels the weight of every apology. But feeling bad about something and changing because of it are two entirely separate actions — and for a long time, he only knew how to do the first one.
The moment Tonya understood this wasn't about Josh's intentions — it was about the pattern of her own waiting — the whole picture shifted.
You don't need perfect. You need consistent. And you need to be able to tell the difference between "I'm sorry" and "I'll do differently."
Pattern 3. The Red Flag Library. All 42 — the ones that look like love until you have the word for them.
Get the Guide on Etsy
